Non-stick or ceramic: which coating survives your kitchen
Almost every cookware set on the market is coated with one of two things: a fluoropolymer non-stick, or a silica-based ceramic. They look similar in a photograph, they cost roughly the same, and they wear out for completely different reasons.
We see a lot of worn cookware come across this counter, so this is written from the failure end rather than the marketing end.
Fluoropolymer non-stick
The familiar dark coating, applied in layers over an aluminium or steel base. It is slippery from the first use and stays that way for a long time if it is treated properly.
How it fails
Mechanically. It is a soft surface, and metal utensils, stacked pans and abrasive sponges scratch it. Once a scratch reaches the base metal, food catches there and the coating lifts around the edges of the scratch. It also degrades above roughly 500°F, which an empty pan on a high burner reaches in a couple of minutes.
What extends it
Wood, silicone or nylon utensils. Medium heat — non-stick does not need high heat, and high heat is what kills it. Hand washing. And never preheating a coated pan empty.
Ceramic
A silica-derived sol-gel coating, usually pale, applied and cured onto the base. Harder than fluoropolymer, tolerant of higher temperatures, and free of fluorinated compounds — which is the main reason most people choose it.
How it fails
Chemically and thermally rather than mechanically. Ceramic starts out extremely slippery and loses that property gradually, whether or not you scratch it. Oil polymerising onto the surface at high heat builds an invisible film that food then sticks to, and thermal shock — a hot pan into cold water — crazes the coating.
The practical consequence: a ceramic pan that has never been scratched can still stop being non-stick within a year or two. That surprises people who chose it expecting it to be the more durable option.
What extends it
Low to medium heat, always. Avoid cooking sprays — the propellant and lecithin in aerosol sprays leave a residue that bakes on and is very difficult to remove. Let a pan cool before washing it. Use a mild detergent, and when food starts sticking, clean with a paste of bicarbonate of soda rather than an abrasive pad.
What is underneath matters more than people think
The coating is a surface. The base determines how the pan cooks.
- Pressed aluminium. Light, cheap, heats fast, and develops hot spots. Fine for eggs, poor for anything that needs even heat.
- Forged or cast aluminium. Thicker, more even, heavier. The sweet spot for most coated cookware.
- Aluminium core with a stainless base. Induction compatible and more stable. Heavier and costlier.
A thin base is the reason a pan warps. Once a base is warped it will never sit flat on a ceramic or induction hob again, and no coating fixes that.
Hob compatibility
Induction needs a ferrous base — if a magnet does not stick to the bottom of the pan, it will not work. This catches out a lot of aluminium cookware, and manufacturers do not always state it prominently. Check for an induction symbol or the phrase “suitable for all hob types”, and if in doubt, ask.
Oven safety, and where the limit actually is
Cookware oven ratings are usually limited by the handle rather than the coating. A pan rated to 350°F often has a phenolic handle; the same pan with a steel handle may be rated to 500°F. Glass lids are frequently rated lower than the pan they belong to, which is why lids crack in ovens.
Read the rating for the specific piece, not for the set.
Counting the pieces
A 19-piece set is not nineteen pans. It typically includes lids, and often utensils and trivets. Convert to actual cooking vessels before comparing sets: a 19-piece and a 12-piece set frequently contain the same six pans.
Think about what you use. Most households cook almost everything in a large skillet, a medium saucepan and a stockpot. A set with three sizes you use and six you do not is worse value than a smaller set of the right pieces.
When a coated pan is finished
When the coating is worn through to the metal over any meaningful area, the pan has finished its life as a non-stick pan. It is not dangerous to use in the ordinary sense, but it will stick, and the loose coating will continue to come away.
Coated pans cannot be re-coated domestically, and industrial re-coating costs more than the pan. This is one of the few appliances where the honest answer really is replacement.
Getting a decade out of a set
- Medium heat. Almost every coated pan is destroyed by high heat.
- Non-metal utensils, without exception.
- Hand wash, and let the pan cool first.
- Never stack pans bare — put a cloth or a pan protector between them.
- No aerosol cooking spray. Oil from a bottle, or butter.
Every cookware set we list from the Santee shop states the coating type, the base construction, the piece count broken down, and the oven rating for the pans and lids separately. If you want to know how a particular range holds up, we probably have one on the bench.
Common questions
Which lasts longer, non-stick or ceramic?
Treated well, fluoropolymer non-stick usually holds its release properties longer. Ceramic is harder and tolerates more heat, but it loses slipperiness gradually even without being scratched.
Why did my ceramic pan stop being non-stick?
Almost always polymerised oil — a thin invisible film baked on at high heat, often from aerosol cooking spray. Clean it with a bicarbonate of soda paste, cook at lower temperatures, and use oil from a bottle instead.
Can a worn non-stick pan be re-coated?
Not domestically, and commercial re-coating costs more than the pan. Once the coating is worn through to the metal over any real area, it has finished its life as a non-stick pan.
Browse the range: all products · about Goldsmith Appliance · ask us a question.